ECJ Case a preliminary ruling regarding German VAT Group rules

Share insight:

Published by the European Union Official Gazette, the European Court of Justice (ECJ) released a preliminary ruling concerning German value-added tax (VAT) group regulations.

A controlling company set up a VAT group for the purpose of streamlining the payment and management of taxes within the group. This allows the members to be treated as one entity for VAT purposes, enabling them to simplify the VAT obligations and reduce their administrative burden.

During an external audit conducted by the tax authority, it was determined that the existing VAT group arrangement was invalid. The reason cited was that the controlling company, which was responsible for setting up the group, was not financially integrated and did not have majority control in terms of voting rights. Consequently, it was decided they did not meet the necessary criteria for establishing a valid VAT group and would, therefore, not be recognized.

Despite the findings of the tax office, the company maintained its stance that it should be classified as a single taxable entity and be eligible to receive the advantages associated with being a member of a VAT grouping.

The ECJ, however, determined that under the EU common VAT system, closely associated entities in a VAT grouping must be viewed as a single taxable entity if the classification carries no risk of tax losses. Furthermore, it was also clarified that according to the provisions of the EU VAT directive, Germany cannot require consolidated financial integration of every member of a VAT group.

Disclaimer: Reproduced/Adapted with permission from Global VAT Compliance. 

Latest news

More Insights

Cookies are used on our site to help give you the best user experience possible and to provide a level of enhanced functionality. If you continue viewing the site without changing your settings, we will assume you are happy to receive all cookies. Your cookie settings can be changed at any time by using the guidelines in our cookie policy. You can also click on the information button for further details.